My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay at this quaint marina in Montauk. George, the owner, went above and beyond making sure we felt welcome, providing assistance to us as we docked and proudly showing us around his place. He has been renovating and making updates over the past couple of years. This marina is clean and offers floating docks, an on-site bar (that happened to have live music while we were there), a ship’s store, fuel dock, laundry, ice, etc. We will definitely be back again! Thank you George for your hospitality!
If I could put zero starts I would. We will never return to this marina (if you can call it that). The dockhands don't have a clue, there are no facilities, and the owners are non-existent. Calling ahead to make sure they are expecting you is a waste of time. Telling them your length and beam is also a waste as they will be surprised when you arrive and try to tie you up to anything they can. If you need to stay in Old Harbor on a dock, do yourself a favor and stay at the town dock. You'll be rafted up, but at least you will be away from the ferry and the infamous underwater hazards that everyone hits at low tide. Avoid this marina at all costs.