I don't understand the bad reviews.I've been going here for over 8 years, I've never had a bad experience! I bring all my clients there because I know They will never embarrass me and their guys on the dock are extremely helpful. The manager always checks to make sure everything is ok and even the owner has asked if we needed anything. They have hands down the best deal in Fire Island not to mention the best location. If I lived closer, I'd go a few times a week!