The dock hands were great and the food at the restaurant was good. The marina itself is not in great shape. low water and my boat actually sat in the sand/mud so long that the paint on the skegs of my outboard motors was worn away. To top it all off, another boat hit my bow pulpit, breaking a part of my railing and damaging the pulpit itself. Hoping that the marina video system has the culprit on video. Bottom line, not sure I would stay there again given the other options on Fire Island.